Here's a draft of the essay I was whining about before:
Life and Love at BYU
This is the last official essay of my undergraduate career, so I wanted to say a few things about what I’ve learned here at BYU, and of course, most of them have to do with love. In 2002 I came here as a transfer student from Clackamas Community College in Oregon after having opted not to take the SAT. I was going to be a painter and I refused to give in to standardized testing. I’d bravely endured nudity for figure drawing during community college art classes and I was on to BYU where they had the models wear swimsuits, to my relief. I was reformed from my rebellious years in high school and I wanted to go to a college with good Mormon kids where I might find a husband, truthfully. My first two terms at BYU seemed like practice. I spent most of my time huffing up and down the stairs south of campus, doing watercolors in my living room, taking piano lessons from a teacher who practically smacked my knuckles and made me cry, and feeling very alone. I saw all the beautiful, talented students here and felt out of place, like a sweaty cow from Oregon who wasn’t used to the altitude or the summer heat. I left after that summer term and went on a mission to Ukraine. Then I came back, no longer a painter, no longer a cow, but lost nonetheless. I didn’t know what I was supposed to be and I didn’t know what to do with myself at all. All I knew was I had a goal, I had to get married.
For the first year after my mission I almost believed that my singular purpose in school was to get married. I hastily started going on dates with just about anyone who would agree or ask me. One of my favorite stories to tell is about a particularly bad first date I went on during that frantic first semester back at school. I don’t remember what his name was, I think I blocked it, but he called me up after finding me on ldsmingles.com (that was a mistake) and asked if I wanted to go on a motorcycle ride. I agreed even though I was in the middle of painting my toenails. I hopped on the back of his Honda and found out mid-ride that we were on our way to Lehi. I imagined we would be going on a leisurely ride through Provo, but I was mistaken. When we got to our amazing destination, he dropped off a folder of work-related papers at some customer’s house and we turned right back around. By the time we got back to my apartment I was chilled to the bone, sore from holding on so tightly out of fear, and hungry. We then had quesadillas, which I provided against Elder Oaks’ counsel. A little while later he was sprawled on my couch with his feet up. When I asked him if he was bored and if he might like to go do something rather than sit in the apartment, he actually said, “You know, I’d better go because I am about to go out with a lot of other girls soon and I don’t want you to get the wrong impression.” I am disappointed in myself that I did not ask him what this impression might be, but I excused him saying that he was free to leave anytime. And by that I meant, please leave now. There were other dates that almost rivaled that incident, but I’ll stop here and just let the story speak for itself.
I learned quickly that finding “the one” was going to take some time and so I forged ahead with my education, testing out majors and finally settling on one after a year or so. I chose Russian. People always ask me, “Why Russian?” I can never come up with a very direct answer, but they always seem comforted by my choice in editing as a minor. “Oh, thank goodness. You can do something with that” they respond and pat me on the arm. From my experience, I haven’t met too many people who actually go directly into their desired vocation, even if they know what it is. Regardless, it was my choice and I still feel good about it. Then I tell them I want to go to graduate school and get a degree in English. More questions follow this statement, most of them hedging on why I chose Russian for my bachelor’s if I am just going to get my master’s in English. To this I say, “Russian’s just like English, it’s just in Russian.” Think about it for a little bit. The literature’s better, that’s partly why I chose it. Maybe the other reason was just to challenge myself.
The following semester, that fall, I went to live in the Foreign Language Student Housing amongst other Russian speaking students. It worked out great with my plan because I would be working in the Missionary Training Center and it was right across the street. It was a wonderful place to live and I met many of my closes friends there. I also met John. When I first saw him he was a brand new return missionary. John was the reclusive, nerdy type that never really got out and just sat in his room getting paler every day staring at his computer screen and reading Wikipedia for fun. In my naïveté, I thought he just needed to get out and socialize. And what better for socializing than hot tubbing? I promptly invited him to come along with me and my roommates that night. At the first mention of such an activity, he backed into the hallway (which was off-limits to girls) and looked like he was about to run back into his room. I assumed the look of panic on his face was post-mission weirdness. But I don’t give up easily. I was going to get to know him. I continued coming over uninvited, hanging out in his living room, and calling a little too frequently. The more I got to know him, the more I liked him. And he seemed not to mind me too much. His innocence was endearing, and he was very patient with my determined efforts to get him to notice me. We even dated for a brief three weeks while I waited patiently to be kissed. It ended in the car as he was taking me to the airport to fly home for Christmas.
He began awkwardly, clearing his throat when his voice cracked, “I need to talk to you about something.”
I patted his knee and gave it a squeeze. “Just say it. It’s all right.” I couldn’t think of anything that required this kind of serious phrase besides a stronger declaration of his feelings. I pushed all my doubts away because I believed he was mine.
My happy train of thought was interrupted as he continued, “I don’t know how you’re going to take this.” I stopped patting his knee and gripped it, causing him to flinch.
He said, “I deal with SSA.” I looked confused. He clarified, “Same-sex attraction.”
I felt the shock go through me like diving into a cold pool. But I wasn’t surprised by what he said. Everything finally made sense. At that moment I thought my life was caving in. Luckily it was just the illusion that I thought was my life. The truth is, everything was actually fine and still is. Even though my boyfriend turned out to be gay.
That was when I stopped looking. I stopped going to ward activities hoping my future husband would be there. I stopped checking out guys in my classes. I definitely cancelled my LDS dating website memberships. But I didn’t stop hoping. I stopped trying and everything went much better from there on out. I had settled comfortably into my major at that point. I never excelled in my Russian grammar classes, but I learned to love the language even more and soon found one of the loves of my life—poetry.
I had never liked poetry. I thought it was overly sentimental and I didn’t understand its form. I loved prose and read voraciously, but for some reason poetry didn’t touch my heart until I heard it in Russian. I memorized a poem by Alexander Pushkin—the father of Russian poetry, akin to our Shakespeare—that went like this:
I loved you, and I probably still do,
And for a while the feeling may remain.
But let my love no longer trouble you,
I do not wish to cause you any pain.
I loved you; and the hopelessness I knew,
The jealousy, the shyness—though in vain -
Made up a love so tender and so true
As may God grant you to be loved again.
It pierced through all the pain that I’d felt in the previous year and I felt like my heart had finally shed its thick, protective layer. I knew that what had happened with John was not anyone’s fault and nothing had actually gone wrong. It went the way it was supposed to because I had to understand some things and so did he. Poetry gave me a way to convey my realizations, even though my poems were unfortunate.
Love seemed as though a cruel joke
I nodded numbly as you spoke
And told me that your heart was true
But there was nothing you could do
Desire is a razor's edge
A heart is not enough to pledge
I begged for you to let me stay
You sighed and wiped the blood away
The keen blade glinted, never fading
A vision blurred, my eyes evading
The truth before me stark and cold
Am I the only one you've told?
It’s not a good poem, and most of my poems aren’t good, but they had an important purpose. They helped me meet Phillip. I felt like I needed to seek him out at our mutual friend’s cabin to ask him about his poetry, even though we were barely acquaintances. I knew I had to do it, just like I knew I had to try and pull John out of his shell. I grabbed his hand and led him over to the leather sofa in front of the fireplace and we sat there for most of the night, sharing our poetry with one another and talking about everything from Celine Dion to Crime and Punishment. We stayed in close contact and after about a week we were sitting on my porch in the unseasonably cold weather, and he was asking me if I would write him on his mission. I was aware that he was going on a mission and I knew I wasn’t an overly-excitable freshman girl who could wait for a missionary or two. But I agreed to write him and we dated until he went into the MTC. There was no question about it by the time he left; I knew I would wait for him.
So, I’m graduating from BYU. I’m 26 years old and I’m waiting for a missionary. When I was 21 and I was running up those concrete stairs by the duck pond I wouldn’t have imagined being where I am right now. I might have thrown myself into the pond if I knew what was coming. But that’s how most things go, in my experience. I never know how hard they are going to be until they are over and all the work’s already been done. I made it through all those agonizing first dates and through my boyfriend telling me he’s gay. I scraped through entire semesters, sleeping in between (and during) classes and living off of pizza bagels from the Twilight Zone. I chose my major and I finished it. I even decided upon a sensible minor, which I don’t regret. Seven months later I am still writing Phillip and I plan on writing him for the next 17. I think I know what to do now. I know who I am. I am not worried about the future even though so much is still undecided. I’m going to keep walking toward the horizon.
“The dawn is not distant, nor is the night starless; love is eternal.”—Henry Wadsworth Longfellow